February 2, 2011

Egypt is Burning

I have been doing a bit of research the past month or so on the French Revolution. In the past I spent far more time on Napoleon and his wars, and I really did not care much to study the Jacobins and the Reign of Terror. I took a class in war and revolution back in college and we read Bacon and Paine and discussed the role of revolution in a general way, but this is the first time in 30 years I really have studied the period.

I have a half formulated post spinning in my brain relating the French Revolution and its extremes to today's world, but nothing coherent has yet found its way to virtual paper. I am not about to begin that essay now, so hold off on letting those eyes glaze over.

It is interesting to compare some of the rhetoric spouted by The Obama and his minions to that of the various French Revolutionaries. Did you know that at the height of the Reign of Terror it was fashionable to be dirty, smelly and sporting rags for clothes? You see, the basis for the Revolution was equality. Appearing in nice clothes, or washed, meant you were trying to be better than the average street dweller. Since the Revolution's roots were the hunger protests of the poor, the homeless and the residents of the slums, no one dared affect the look of the "Aristos". Somehow, the idea of equal opportunity espoused in the American Revolution was perverted to "equal outcome" by the French. Does that position sound familiar?

Some experts are amazed at the rapidity of Revolution in Tunisia and Egypt. History shows the people can overthrow a government in very little time. We have many examples beyond the French. Look at the rapid fall of the Communist Bloc and the Berlin Wall. Unless a regime is prepared to brutally suppress the revolt, the mass of the people can fast overwhelm any government. A hesitant military will allow the people to overcome the police and law enforcement. It is interesting to note the police in most revolutions side with the regime in power. The linchpin is always the military. Will soldiers fire upon their fellow citizens?

In 1956 Hungary, it was not the Hungarian Army that put down the revolt. It was the Soviets. Foreign armies of occupation are far more willing to  shoot would-be revolutionaries and suppress rebellion. It has been reported China brought in troops from the distant provinces to put down the Tienanmen Square revolt, afraid troops from Beijing would hesitate.

In Egypt, the police have tried to suppress the protests. The key is the role the military will take.  Remember, it is the military that really controls Egypt. In any case, a change in regime can not bode well for our relations with Egypt. Israel will find a far more Islamist state next door than previously.  These events can not be positive for oil prices, for regional stability, for the War on Terror.

We should not be surprised when similar events occur across the Middle East in the coming months. Oppression, poverty and a vast difference in the standard of living between the ruling class and the people will in the end precipitate a revolution.  The rise of the people will be fast and furious. And little good will come of it.  Rage is never a good formula for governance.

4 comments:

CnC said...

The most likely outcome of a revolution in Egypt will be the muslim brotherhood hijacking the movement and installing a lunatic as leader; much like what happened in Iran after they and Jimmy Carter overthrew the Shaw.

Grumpyunk said...

I for 1 would be interested in reading more on the revolution.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

nM1C3g http://bootsclearance.moonfruit.com/ uS6M5z [url=http://bootsclearance.moonfruit.com/]uggs clearance[/url] rI9V2a clearance uggs jT9Z7a
nA7T6y http://bootsoutletstore.webs.com/ hG4J1y [url=http://bootsoutletstore.webs.com/]ugg outlet stores[/url] vK7I0g uggs outlet stores sR0U0l
vE9P8c http://bootsonline.blinkweb.com ugg outlet online aW3V0o [url=http://bootsonline.blinkweb.com]cheap uggs online[/url] cE5R7j uggs outlet online sG5V6g
sY9N0c http://bootssales.webs.com/ pD9Q4f [url=http://bootssales.webs.com/]uggs on sale usa[/url] jV6V8e ugg boots sale nO8K8x
zD0I0d http://genuineboot.webeden.co.uk kF1B1a[url=http://genuineboot.webeden.co.uk]genuine ugg boots uk[/url] dC5J3x real ugg boots kR9V9a
lG3D4k http://cheapbootsuk.jimdo.com/ hN3O1a [url=http://cheapbootsuk.jimdo.com/]ugg boots sale uk[/url] cP5R4f cheap uggs uk bA5E2a

Consider everything here that is of original content copyrighted as of March 2005